Vietnamese Verses Chinese Retail Investors (AFC)
The July newsletter from Asia Frontier Capital (AFC) observed that the rapid and seemingly chaotic development of the Chinese stock market over the past 12 months has shown how retail investors can create a stock market rally or bubble and eventually let the bubble burst as well. However, things are different with the Vietnam stock market where small retail investors are currently missing from the market. Moreover and despite the fact that domestic investors in Vietnam are already responsible for 80% – 90% of trading activities, there has been an absence of new investors coming online (the current press coverage of China’s stock markets in the Vietnamese as well as global media is not helping to attract new investors to the Vietnam stock market). Currently, active local Vietnamese investors are mainly following shares attracting foreign buyers – meaning they have primarily only showed interest in a handful of index names.
Vietnam also doesn’t produce statistics about new brokerage accounts. In China at the height of the recent bull market, 1.6 million new accounts were opened in just one week with the infamous stereotype that taxi drivers and housewives were driving the last phase of a stock market rally largely being confirmed by some of the data.
AFC goes on to note that there are clear parallels in the development of the Chinese and Vietnamese stock markets. In the 25 years since the Chinese stock market debut, there were four market bubbles with excessive valuations and an increase of the index between 150% and >1000% in a relatively short time period. In the 15 year old history of the Vietnamese stock market, there have been only two comparable bubbles with a 400% gain and similar valuations (2001/2007).
These stock market bubbles and bursts are not an exclusive phenomenon of either country as we have seen this occur in recent decades in other Asia markets such as Japan, Taiwan and Thailand. Then there are American or European investors who are willing to pay 50-100 times earnings for social media/tech/dot.com/green/3D printing stocks despite the fact that many of them are not even profitable or have no hopes of profits. AFC observed:
In my experience it usually does not matter to the majority of market participants whether a listed company is being valued at a price/earnings ratio of 5x or 50x as long as one expects further gains.
To read the whole newsletter or AFC Vietnam Fund – Manager Comment, go to the website of Asia Frontier Capital (AFC). In addition, check out our China closed-end fund list, China ETF list and Vietnam ETF list.
- How Investors Can Predict Future Vietnam Protests or Disruptions (CAA)
- Nigeria, Argentina and Vietnam Top the Frontier Markets Sentiment Index (WSJ)
- Vietnam: In a Sweet Spot (AFC Asia Frontier Fund)
- Digging Deeper: Vietnam’s Stock Market Reforms and Frontier Market Status Update (July 2022)
- Russell Frontier Markets Equity Fund’s Manager Sees Neglected Gems (WSJ)
- The Emerging Asia Pacific Capital Markets: Vietnam (CFA Institute)
- Apocalypse Now For Investors? A Realistic Vietnam Investment Review
- Trade War Steers Chinese Investment Toward Southeast Asia (Nikkei Asian Review)
- Low Rates and a Pandemic Usher New Traders Into Vietnamese Stocks (Nikkei Asia)
- Vietnam to make Apple Watch and MacBook for first time ever (Nikkei Asia)
- Economic Prospects in Several Emerging Asia Countries (Wells Fargo Securities)
- Looking Past the Hang-Ups for Asia’s Smartphone Industry (Franklin Templeton)
- Are There Greater Opportunities In Asia’s Frontier Markets Than in China? (FT)
- Vietnam Economy Grows Nearly 7% on Trade War Tailwinds (Nikkei Asian Review)
- VanEck Vietnam ETF (VNM): Flawed But Still an Easy Way to Cash in on Vietnam’s Frontier to Emerging Market Upgrade (EMS Substack)